I've recently installed a plugin that broke the site. So I deactivated all other plugins and activated one at a time until the site broke again. I narrowed it down. This new plugin and an old one just don't get along. The problem is that I need both of them. They are both very unique.
What can I do to try and get them to work together and not break the site? I'm asking general items that people usually try in such cases. Is my only course to ask the plugin developers for support? I'm worried that both plugin developers will just blame the other plugin and pass the buck, leaving me with no support either way.