WordPress Development Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for WordPress developers and administrators. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

What experiences have you had with MarketPress vs. other WP ecommerce solutions? I found a client that wants to use it and I never worked with it before.

How does it compare with WooCommerce or WP e-Commerce? Or does anyone know of a good and recent comparison of WordPress ecommerce solutions? ...everything I find on this is either shallow or old...

share|improve this question

closed as not constructive by Michael, Stephen Harris, Wyck, Bainternet Jul 7 '12 at 17:16

As it currently stands, this question is not a good fit for our Q&A format. We expect answers to be supported by facts, references, or expertise, but this question will likely solicit debate, arguments, polling, or extended discussion. If you feel that this question can be improved and possibly reopened, visit the help center for guidance.If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

up vote 4 down vote accepted

Questions like this is are not really suitable for WPSE because they attract a lot of subjective, open ended opinion, for which there is often no right answer.

Let me give you a real world example.

I have used several WordPress E-commerce plugins, both free and premium types, I've also created my own custom solutions in certain cases too.

However I often recommend JigoShop which is free and from my experience I have found it to be a very robust commerce platform for WordPress, that appears well coded and in the instances where I have used it for client projects I've extended or modified its functionality where needed.

If you are also a developer which I'm getting a hint of (?) seeing as this is for a client, then if you know your way around the WordPress API, you too would be able to use something like JigoShop to its full extent and power and in a situation where you need something a little off-beat, dive right in and extend its functionality.

The same could also be said for a host of other commerce type plugins.

Now back to the issue with questions like this, I've completely ignored mentioning Market Press and in place of something entirely different and while that's what you want to know in part, my opinion is subjective based upon my experience and skill level so much so that what I say could sway you one way or another to make a decision that's not right for you, or possibly entirely right.

When you couple that with several people all recommending different commerce platforms, you're going to be in a position of more confusion than certainty which is why questions like this should remain simply Google searches, to see what others are saying about _Market Press_ vs _The Rest_.

  • You want to look for people who have reviewed Market Press, legitimately, ideally not people who are affiliates of products too as their reviews are mostly biased.

  • You should also compare the list of features the product has versus other similar products in the market to see if they meet your needs.

There are popular known contenders (and many more) in this space such as,

  • Cart66
  • WooCommerce
  • GetShopped
  • Shopp
  • Tribulant WordPress Shopping Cart
  • and more...

At one point I had wanted to test Tribulant WordPress Shopping Cart, but opted for JigoShop and have never had the need to go back to try Tribulant's solution. I have also used Cart66 and found that to be a good solution too, but again, it comes down to features required, both now and in the future, which is why any opinion you receive here can do you more harm than good.

If you choose a particular plugin over another, then wish to extend the plugin with a unique feature or possible work out how to achieve a particular way of accessing/presenting data then this is where WPSE becomes your place of choice because questions relating to code that have tangible answers, right answers in respect to their functionality are the types of questions we like and the types of questions you'll receive the most helpful answers for.

PS. Just a quick side note, you'll notice when you go to reply as a comment to an answer you are limited by the amount of characters you can write in response. This is intentional and its not really an issue of increased database size either. Its designed for the most part (even if indirectly) NOT to promote back and forth discussion but rather Question->Answer->Clarification (in the form of Comment).

share|improve this answer
Thanks a lot for the reply, but i was hoping to attract a lot of subjective answers - hoping some of them will also be well informed and thus get upvoted! (Sidenote: Isn't such a site intended to be used as a "hive mind" that throws lots of answers back at you but properly sorted by the collective intelligence of others? I don't even like the fact that you can only mark one answer as "right".) – NeuronQ Jul 7 '12 at 16:33
Questions like this mostly get closed because they don't meet the requirements outlined in the FAQ. Its understandable, as WPSE is more about the technical help/code challenges of WP than open ended debate. Tthe "e-commerce" topic has been thrashed. However, like you, also like open debates/discussion but if it were allowed, the real technical help would get drowned out and there is nothing else like WPSE for free on such a level. Feel free to stop by our chat room because that's the place for open discussion with some very experienced devs! – userabuser Jul 7 '12 at 16:45
Any answers to this question won't do you much justice because most people who answer these types of open ended questions (especially e-commerce plugin questions) rarely if ever provide sufficient evidence or support in what they're saying. Take a look and see for yourself. Its thin advice. Even my answer, while it provides opinion, doesn't give you a side by side run-down which is time consuming to write. Not everyone has that will. There is nothing greater a benefit than you'll receive by comparing features against client requirements, then coming to chat about them in our chat room. – userabuser Jul 7 '12 at 16:52
Ok, I understand you points. And thanks for suggesting me the chat room as a better place for such discussions! I'll let the question open for a few more hours just to see what/who "lands on it" and then I'll pick yours as the right answer and close it. Thanks for taking the time to explain instead of just closing it! – NeuronQ Jul 7 '12 at 16:56
Off-topic, but need to say: kudos for such nice write-up, @userabuser! Excellent candidate for a meta-Q&A, or simply an A if a Q already exists there :) – brasofilo Jul 7 '12 at 17:21

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.