I'm quite shocked to learn that out of all the Restrict Access plugins for WordPress, there's not one I can find that suits my needs. Basically I have two requirements: Do not display the page in wp_list_pages and Do not display the page in search results.
I tried 7 plugins: Members, Advanced Access Manager, Restrict Content, Page Security, Maven Member, User Access Manager, and WordPress Access Control.
Advanced Access Manager was the only plugin that restricted the page from being displayed on the wp_list_pages. WordPress Access Control is the only plugin that explicitly addressed the search issue.
Am I going to have to use 2 plugins to meet my requirements?